Skip to main content

Table 4 Evaluation of included trial studies using the CONSORT-CHM statement

From: Efficacy and safety of traditional Chinese medicines for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease: a systematic literature review of randomized controlled trials

Number Authors, year Title/abstract Background Objectives Trial design Participants Interventions Outcomes Sample size Randomization Allocation Implementation Blinding Statistical methods
1 Wu et al., 2020 × ×
2 Lyv et al., 2020 × ×
3 Yang et al., 2019 × × ×
4 Yang et al., 2019 × × × ×
5 Li et al., 2018 × ×
6 Chen 2017 × × ×
7 Hu et al., 2017 × × ×
8 Jiang et al., 2017 × × ×
9 Yang et al., 2017 × ×
10 Jeong et al., 2017 × ×
11 Sun et al., 2017 × × × ×
12 Niu 2016 × × ×
13 Zhang et al., 2016 ×
14 Zhang et al., 2016 × × × ×
15 Qi et al., 2016 × × ×
16 Tan et al., 2016 × × × ×
17 Yu et al., 2016 × × ×
18 Yin et al., 2016 × ×
19 Zhu 2015 × × ×
20 Li 2015 × × × × ×
21 Chen et al., 2015 ×
22 Yu et al.,2015 × × ×
23 Li 2015 × ×
24 Liu et al., 2014 × × ×
25 Liu et al., 2014 × × × ×
26 Li et al., 2014
27 Zhu et al., 2014 × ×
28 Wen et al., 2014 × × × ×
29 Deng, 2013 × × ×
30 Li et al., 2013 × × ×
31 Song et al., 2013 × × × ×
32 Li et al., 2013 × ×
33 Wong et al., 2013
34 Pan et al., 2013 × ×
35 Chen et al., 2012 × × ×
36 Zhao et al., 2012
37 Wang et al., 2012 × × ×
38 Pei et al.,2012 × × ×
39 Wu et al., 2012 × × × × ×
40 Tong et al., 2011 × ×
41 Zhang et al., 2011 × × ×
42 Gu et al., 2011 × ×
43 Zhao et al., 2010 × × ×
44 Ding et al., 2010 × ×
45 Pan et al., 2010 × ×
46 Liu et al.,2008
47 Ji et al., 2008 × ×
48 Chen et al., 2008 × ×
49 Lou et al., 2008
50 Li et al., 2007 × ×
51 Yang et al., 2007 × × × ×
52 Gu et al., 2007 × ×
53 Chen et al., 2006 × ×
Number Authors, year Participant flow Recruitment Baseline data Numbers analysed Outcomes Ancillary analysis Harms Limitations Generalizability Interpretation Registration Protocol Funding
1 Wu et al., 2020 × × × × × ×
2 Lyv et al., 2020 × × × × × ×
3 Yang et al., 2019 × × × × ×
4 Yang et al., 2019 × × × × × ×
5 Li et al., 2018 × × × ×
6 Chen 2017 × × × × × ×
7 Hu et al., 2017 × × × × ×
8 Jiang et al., 2017 × × × × ×
9 Yang et al., 2017 × × × × × × ×
10 Jeong et al., 2017 × × ×
11 Sun et al., 2017 × × × × × ×
12 Niu 2016 × × × × × ×
13 Zhang et al., 2016 × × × × × ×
14 Zhang et al., 2016 × × × × × × ×
15 Qi et al., 2016 × × × × × × ×
16 Tan et al., 2016 × × × × × ×
17 Yu et al., 2016 × × × × × ×
18 Yin et al., 2016 × × × × × ×
19 Zhu 2015 × × × × × × ×
20 Li 2015 × × × × ×
21 Chen et al., 2015 × × × × ×
22 Yu et al.,2015 × × × × ×
23 Li 2015 × × × × × ×
24 Liu et al., 2014 × × × × × × × ×
25 Liu et al., 2014 × × × × ×
26 Li et al., 2014 × × × × ×
27 Zhu et al., 2014 × × × × × × ×
28 Wen et al., 2014 × × × × × ×
29 Deng, 2013 × × × × × × × ×
30 Li et al., 2013 × × × × × ×
31 Song et al., 2013 × × × × × × ×
32 Li et al., 2013 × × × × ×
33 Wong et al., 2013 × ×
34 Pan et al., 2013 × ×
35 Chen et al., 2012 × × × × × ×
36 Zhao et al., 2012 × × ×
37 Wang et al., 2012 × × × × × × ×
38 Pei et al.,2012 × × × × ×
39 Wu et al., 2012 × × × ×
40 Tong et al., 2011 × × × × × ×
41 Zhang et al., 2011 × × × × × ×
42 Gu et al., 2011 × × × × × ×
43 Zhao et al., 2010 × × × × × × × ×
44 Ding et al., 2010 × × × × × × ×
45 Pan et al., 2010 × × × × × × ×
46 Liu et al.,2008 × × × × × × ×
47 Ji et al., 2008 × × × × ×
48 Chen et al., 2008 × × × × × × ×
49 Lou et al., 2008 × × × ×
50 Li et al., 2007 × × × × × × ×
51 Yang et al., 2007 × × × × × × ×
52 Gu et al., 2007 × × × × ×
53 Chen et al., 2006 × × × × ×