- Open Access
Clarifying the origin of Houzao
© The Author(s) 2018
Received: 26 March 2018
Accepted: 20 April 2018
Published: 3 May 2018
Indian Houzao originates from Indian goats rather than from macaques; it comes from goats and not sheep, and is not limited to female goats.
The exact location of the bezoar is in the caecum and not stomach or intestines.
Acacia seeds serve as the primer to induce the formation of bezoar in the caecum.
The formation and development of the bezoar are closely related to the special local ecosystem and food chain. These goats eat the shoots of Acacia nilotica, and also other local plants in the families of Euphorbiaceae, Rutaceae, Combretaceae, etc.
It takes around 120 days for the bezoar to be fully developed inside the goat. Many goats are slaughtered in the Indian festival Dusserah from October to December.
Our study has clarified the origin of Indian Houzao, which can help to further develop Indian Houzao for the treatment of diseases.
Houzao (bezoar) is an imported and valuable pediatric Chinese medicine used to transform phlegm . The 《飲片新參》 (Yinpian xin can)  of The National TCM Pharmacopoeia Prescription Collection  has records of different Houzao-containing Chinese medicine formulations collected from different areas, including Shanghai, Nanjing and Hangzhou. Since 1997, China has listed “Houzao San” (“Houzao Powder”) as an essential Chinese medicine for emergency medicine . Clinically, Houzao San is mainly used for the treatment of fever, bronchitis, pneumonia, asthma and patients with symptoms of interior heat [5–13]. At present, there are 11 manufacturers producing Houzao-related products in mainland China. In Hong Kong, more than a hundred manufacturers have registered Houzao-related products, two of which have their products sold in the mainland Chinese market.
Houzao is described in the Chinese Materia Medica (Zhong Hua Ben Cao) as the gastrointestinal concretions of Macaca mulatta Zimmermann or Macaca speciosa F. Cuvier in the Family Cercopithecidae. The concretion can be collected year-round from the gastrointestinal tract after the animals are killed. The concretion is dried in ventilated place. Production regions include India, the Malay Peninsula and the Malay Archipelago .
The earliest record of Houzao dates back to 1930, in one of the Chen Renshan’s writings named Yaowu Chuchan Bian (“Analysis of the Production Regions of Medicinals”). This text clarified the origins of Houzao, noting that a stone is developed from the essence of the animal in the stomach, liver and gallbladder, accumulating over years in old monkeys that have long consumed wild fruits. The shape of Houzao is similar to jujubes and it is similar to the bezoar of a cow or a dog, and therefore has similar therapeutic effects . Since then, many academic writings in China describe Houzao as the gastrointestinal bezoar of macaques in the family Cercopithecidae; however, the historical origin of Houzao is still controversial. Indeed, Chen Renshan already questioned the origin of Houzao. Chen mentioned that “the local people from its production regions in the Malay Archipelago refer to it as a goat intestine stone, there must a reason for this.” An early study in 1979 by Zhang  and others also pointed out that the stones of macaques and goats appear morphologically similar but differ in the features of their cross-section, allowing for differentiation.
To clarify the identity of Houzao, the National Pharmaceutical Administration organized a site visit to India in 1985. The investigation concluded that Houzao is a bezoar formed in the gastrointestinal tract of female goats . Subsequent publications frequently repeated this conclusion [17–20]. Yu  and others used X-rays to analyze the diffraction patterns of Malaysian Houzao and Indian Houzao, and the results indicated that they have different compositions. In 1984, in issue 5 of the Journal of the Chinese Herbal Medicine, Qiu  identified the difference between Malaysian Houzao and Indian Houzao. He reported that Houzao was derived from processed or semi-processed animal bezoars. Xue and Yi  found that Houzao contains bile but is not a gallstone. They hypothesized that Houzao consists of seeds or other debris that serves as the core, and is surrounded by layers of a mixture of bile in goats, monkeys or other animals; over time the bezoar forms in the stomach or gallbladder of a goat or monkey, then it is removed for grinding and further processing. Sun  also suggests that Houzao is not the bezoar of a monkey, but is a kind of gastrointestinal phosphate-carbonate concretion like the bezoar of a horse or dog, which can be cultivated and produced like the bezoar of cow.
To investigate the origin of Houzao, we paid a visit to a senior in the field of traditional Chinese medicine in Hong Kong, Mr. Lee Chun Hung. Mr. Lee is over 80 years old, and has been selling valuable Chinese medicines in Hong Kong for more than 60 years. His shop has a collection of many precious Chinese medicines, including different types of Houzao. Mr. Lee describes Houzao as an imported medicinal. There are two kinds of Houzao with two product specifications: the first kind is the “Houzao” that comes from Malaysia, while the other kind is called “Indian Houzao” that comes from India (it is recognized as an intestinal bezoar from goats). Historically, Houzao did not refer to a bezoar from the gastrointestinal tract, but rather referred to a bezoar formed in the cheek pouch of macaques in Southeast Asia. Macaques store food in their cheek pouches and later consume this reserve slowly. If there are pebbles or twigs that cannot be digested, the macaque will secrete a protective membrane around the debris to avoid inflammation or damage. The secretion will grow thicker and gradually form into a bezoar. However, the annual supply of such bezoars from macaques is only around a dozen kilograms worldwide, and is occasionally mixed with bezoars from other monkeys or apes. The origin of such bezoars is unclear and cannot be traced, with an unstable supply that risks decline and extinction. Mr. Lee stated that goat bezoars where originally produced in Iran, but were later sourced from India. Every year, about 200–400 kg of Houzao (goat bezoars) are available on the market. In addition to being used as single product, they are often used in compound Chinese medicine products. Within the industry, the goat bezoars are also referred to as yang chang zao (羊腸棗, “goat intestine jujubes”). He believes that goat bezoars have been traded in China for at least 200–300 years.
We also contacted the two Hong Kong manufacturers of Houzao-related products, “Po Wo Tong Pharmaceutical Limited” and “Eu Yan Sang”. These companies confirmed that 100% of the Houzao they use for their products is the goat bezoar form (yang chang zao羊腸棗).
In the March of 2018, we have paid a visit to Mr. Jin Shi-yuan, a master Chinese medicine practitioner in Beijing. Mr. Jin has been engaged in the Chinese medicine industry for nearly 80 years. He describes Houzao as similar to the gallstone of a cow; both are traditionally well-known as imported and valuable Chinese medicines. While circumstances did not allow him to have the chance to conduct a site visit to investigate the origins of Houzao, he is familiar with it. Currently, most local manufacturers are mainly in the south of China, such as Shanghai, Hangzhou, and Nanjing. In his memory, the Houzao he observed were similar, with a flat and oval shape and shiny blue color; authentic products make a sound when shaken together.
In summary, many professionals in the TCM industry suspected that Houzao is not derived from a single kind of animal. It is also acknowledged that Indian Houzao comes from a goat rather than a monkey; however, it is not known if other goat breeds can also produce such bezoars. Some have speculated that a portion of the Houzao on the market is artificially produced in goats. However, thus far no professionals in the Chinese medicine field have visited India to conduct on-site investigation and witness the production and collection of Houzao; instead, they primarily receive information through the descriptions of local traders. To date, since none of the published data describes the collection of the bezoar from macaques or goats based on eyewitness reports, the speculative ideas referenced above lack a concrete answer.
Accordingly, in the mid-January in 2018, we visited south-central India to investigate the origin of the Houzao that dominates the market, to explore where it comes from, how it is formed, how the food chain affects its formation, and how it is collected.
The field investigation
Our on-site investigation was conducted in Telangana province in south-central India, which is a mixed farming and pastoral area. It produces cotton, corn, rice and fruits, and has both dry and wet seasons.
We were led by Mr. Aijaz Mahboob Khan (A. M. Khan), who is specialized in the local Houzao business. After four hours of driving from Hyderabad, we reached Karimnagar and Warangal on the first day; we went to Nizamabad on the second day. We visited two shepherd families in the two villages and dissected two domestic Indian goats on-site. The first goat we dissected was a male goat, the second one was a female goat. Mr. Huan Yiping and Mr. Chai Lin recorded the whole dissection process. We also collected some plant specimens, which are now kept in the Chinese Medicines Center of the Bank of China and School of Chinese Medicine in Hong Kong Baptist University (Nos. ZZZ2018-India001 to 006).
Formation of the bezoar
The area is home to many goats (Capra aegagrus hircus), which have horns and dark brown to black bodies. These goats usually weigh between 10 and 20 kg. They have a long head, short neck and large ears. The males and females have a pair of horns at the forehead, with larger horns on the males. The jaws of the males have long whiskers. They have 4 thin limbs and a short tail, and their entire body is covered by coarse, straight, short hair. The hair ranges in color from black, gray, or brown, sometimes with other combinations. In general, female goats can become pregnant twice a year, each time giving birth to 2–4 kids; it takes 6 months for a kid to grow into an adult.
The Indian black goats live as a herd. They are strong foragers and eat many varieties of grass, trees and leaves. In April, after the fruits of the tree “Tumma chettu” (Acacia nilotica) mature, the local people tap the branches with sticks to harvest the fruits and collect the seeds. Since the seeds are bitter, they are soaked in salt water before being fed to the goats.
Experienced shepherds will know if the goats have the potential to accumulate the seeds by touching the goat’s abdomen; goats that do not tend to accumulate the seeds will be taken to a normal pasture and will be raised for meat; the goats that tend to accumulate the seeds will be taken to the forest to graze on specific plants. They are transported deep into the mountains to be raised in remote camps in the forest, where they are fed specific plants to facilitate the formation of the bezoars. The grazing period starts from the wet season in June, when the local vegetation flourishes. In the dry season in November, the goats are slaughtered for meat and the bezoars are collected. It takes approximately 120 days for the bezoar to be fully formed inside the goat after feeding on the Acacia seeds.
In the Chinese literature, it is incorrectly stated that only female goats can produce bezoars. Indeed, both male and female goats can produce bezoars.
The food chain of the Capra aegagrus hircus
The food chain is closely associated with the formation of bezoars in goats.
Acacia nilotica (L.) Delile originated in Africa and spread to Arabia, Afghanistan and India. It is now cultivated worldwide. In China, it is cultivated in Hainan, Yunnan and other regions.
Anogeissus latifolia, Combretaceae;
Cleistanthus collinum, Euphorbiaceae,
Bridela montana, Euphorbiaceae,
Chloroxylon swietenia, Rutaceae,
Tamarindus indica, Fabaceae.
These plants flourish from the beginning of the wet season in early June until November, and provide ample food for the goats during the grazing period. The bezoar is thus produced by feeding specific plants to the goats.
The collection of the goat bezoar (羊腸棗)
After they fall into the caecum of the goats, the acacia seeds are not excreted and serve as the “primer” to induce the secretion of anti-inflammatory substances to protect the goat from irritation by the seed. Since the seeds are rich in tannins, anti-inflammatory substances coagulate with the proteins to form a natural protective layer on the surface.
The Dusserah legend comes from the ancient epic Ramayana of India. After being exiled by the King for 14 years, Prince Ram eventually rescued his wife, Sita, from Devil’s Island and returned to her hometown, the whole country welcomed the goddess Lakshmi. Local people celebrate this traditional event by setting up thousands of goat feasts. According to the traditional Indian calendar, Dusserah is usually between October and December each year. At this festival, many goats are slaughtered and the meat is consumed.
Each goat can produce around 5–7 g of bezoars (5–10 pieces of bezoars). Usually, there are 2500–3000 bezoars in 1 kg. Thus, it takes approximately 175 selected goats to produce 1 kg of bezoars. A 1-year-old goat usually weighs 10–15 kg; a whole goat can only be sold for approximately $300 Hong Kong Dollars (~$38 US dollars) for its meat, and its skin is not valuable. However, if there are bezoars in the goat, the shepherd can earn more from the bezoars than from the meat. Therefore, herding goats that produce bezoars is a good way of earning income for the local people.
Identification of the medicinal materials
Identification and characterization of goat bezoar (yangchang zao, 羊腸棗) (Indian Houzao) (bezoar from the caecum of Indian goat Capra aegagrus hircus)
Identification and characterization of Southeast Asian Houzao (bezoar from the cheek pouch of macaques)
Discussion and conclusion
The origin and fact: The Indian Houzao available in the market originates from Indian goats but not from macaques or sheep, and is not limited to female goats. These are domestic goats but not wild goats. The exact location of the bezoar is in the caecum instead of the stomach or large intestine tract. Acacia seeds serve as the primer to induce the formation of the bezoar in the caecum, and the formation and development of the bezoar are closely related to the local habitat and food chain. These goats eat the shoots of Acacia nilotica, and also other local plants in the families of Euphorbiaceae, Rutaceae, Combretaceae, etc. It takes around 120 days for the bezoar to be fully developed inside the goat.
Confirmation of the Chinese nomenclature: We propose to use the Chinese name Yangchang zao (羊腸棗) (also known as Indian Houzao), which can clearly indicate that it is a bezoar formed in the caecum of Indian goat (Capra aegagrus hircus), and the bezoar is formed with the acacia seed at its core. Firstly, the name Yangchang zao (羊腸棗) is scientifically based. Secondly, this name has already been recorded by professionals, and has the same meaning as the name that is being used in the country of origin. Furthermore, although it is more accurate to name it as “bezoar from the caecum of a goat”, the proposed name Yangchang zao (羊腸棗) will easily accepted by the pharmaceutical industry and the general public. In short, the name Yangchang zao (羊腸棗) does not only inherit the history of this traditional medicine, but is also scientifically based.
Bezoar as a detoxification ingredient has been mentioned in the worldwide best-selling novel “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince”. The book says, “bezoar is an antidote to all poisons.”  Goat bezoar has a long history in European culture as well.
Goats are successfully raised worldwide, and goat bezoar is sustainable from the perspective of animal protection, so yangchang zao (羊腸棗) has the potential to be a widely accepted Chinese medicinal material (CMM) by the general public.
There is a rich variety of CMMs, and each has its own history. The famous physician Li Shizhen stated that different herbal medicines were popular between ancient times and the contemporary period he lived in. Historically, some CMMs have been continued while others have been changed.
There are two main criteria that are necessary for a CMM to become a principal or authentic source: (i) reliable therapeutic efficacy and (ii) a rich source of supply . Goat bezoar (yangchang zao羊腸棗) (Indian Hauzao) has been used historically and it has a stable supply source. In south-central India, there are suitable plants and a suitable environment for grazing by goats. Furthermore, sophisticated local cultivation techniques guarantee a sustainable supply of the bezoars for the market. Therefore, goat bezoar (yangchang zao羊腸棗) deserves an in-depth investigation.
The Houzao available in the market is commonly used in scientific research . However, we should take into consideration that the biological compositions of the seed kernel and the bezoar shell of the kernel are different. Pharmacological and clinical studies mainly focus on the compound Chinese proprietary medicine “Houzao san”. The reported pharmacology and therapeutic efficacy of the multicomponent “Houzao san” cannot represent the pharmacology and therapeutic efficacy of the single bezoar on its own (yangchang zao 羊腸棗). Therefore, after clarifying the origin, we should conduct chemical, pharmacological and clinical research on goat bezoar (yangchang zao羊腸棗, Indian Houzao), which can provide solid scientific data for future development, production and application.
Ancient Chinese medicine has always incorporated foreign medicinal products. Clarifying the origin of medicinals is necessary to ensure that the public has access to authentic and high-quality medicines.
ZZZ and EB went to India for the on-site trip and collected specimens. ZZZ, EB, KHY, QBH and ZM conducted the literature searches. ZZZ, EB and KHY drafted the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We are grateful to Mr. Lee Chun Hung, Mr. Chun Kwong Shing, Mr. Jin Shi-yuan and Eu Yan Sang for their enthusiastic support. We also thank for Mr Aijaz Mahboob Khan (A.M. Khan) for his guidance in the Indian trip. The identities of the native plants were confirmed by Prof. Sauris Panda of the Plant Taxonomy Laboratory at the University of Calcutta, India. We also thank for Mr. Huan Yiping and Mr. Chai Lin for recording the whole process of the on-site visit in India.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
All data used in this manuscript are available in the public domain.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Jiangsu New Medical College. Dictionary of Traditional Chinese Medicine (Part 2). Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press; 1977. p. 2412.Google Scholar
- Wang Y. Yinpian xin can (New Reference on Decoction Pieces). Shanghai: Shanghai Qian Qing Tang Bookstore; 1936. p. 26.Google Scholar
- National Formulations for Traditional Chinese Patent Medicines. Beijing: People’s Medical Publishing House; 1964. p 108.Google Scholar
- Standards of the State Food and Drug Administration (Trial) YBZ12812006; 1997.Google Scholar
- Yan H. Zhu Po Houzao San treatment of acute upper respiratory tract infection in 120 cases. Mod Chin Med. 2011;5:30–1.Google Scholar
- Chen T. Zhu Po Houzao San treatment and prevention for repeated upper respiratory tract infection in 60 cases. Chin J Rural Med Pharm. 2011;11:26.Google Scholar
- He J, Rao H, Li Z. Therapeutic effects of Fanfushu and Houzao San in the treatment of children with repeated respiratory infections and their effects on immune globulin. Guiding J Trad Chin Med Pharm. 2009;12:13–4.Google Scholar
- Xiao C. Clinical observation of 58 cases of asthma in children treated with beclomethasone and Houzao San. Mod J Integr Trad West Med. 2002;17:1675.Google Scholar
- Min Z. Houzao San treatment in 38 children with bronchial asthma. Shanghai J Trad Chin Med Pharm. 2006;40(11):42.Google Scholar
- Cai Y, Zheng L, Guo X. Preliminary observation of acute laryngitis complicated by laryngeal obstruction treated with Chinese and Western medicine. J Zhejiang Med Sci. 1965;2:38–9.Google Scholar
- Ma M. Clinical observation of Houzao San combined with Western medicine treatment for bronchiolitis in 40 cases. Zhejiang J Integr Trad West Med. 1997;7(5):267–8.Google Scholar
- Yu J, Zheng X, Zhao Z. Observation of the treatment effect of Houzao San and cow bezoar on bronchial pneumonia in 50 cases. Strait Pharm J. 2011;23(2):132.Google Scholar
- Chang T. Shuang Huang Lian and Houzao San in the treatment of bronchiolitis. Hebei J Integr Trad Chin West Med. 1998;7(1):67–8.Google Scholar
- State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Editorial Board of Chinese Herbs Zhong Hua Ben Cao, vol. 9. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press; 1999. p. 528.Google Scholar
- Chen R. Identification of the origins of materia medica, vol. 58. Guangdong: Guangdong School of Chinese Medicine Specialty Press; 1930.Google Scholar
- China National Institute for the Identification of Pharmaceutical and Biological Products. Guangdong Provincial Institute for Drug Control, Illustrated Authentication of Chinese Materia Medica, vol. 1. Guangdong: Guangdong Science and Technology Press; 1995. p. 197.Google Scholar
- Liu H, Er CB, Zhu Z, Madong Z, Du Y. Medicinal bezoars and medicinal treasures in the abdomen, an investigation into bezoars. Chin J Ethnomed Ethnopharm. 1994;11:11–2.Google Scholar
- Hongqian F. Veterinary prescription references from the Qing Dynasty “Supplement to the Compendium of Materia Medica”. Agric History China. 2001;20(1):84.Google Scholar
- Yueming W. Houzao and goat bezoar. J Chin Herb Med. 1988;11(3):28.Google Scholar
- Liangdong Q. Identification of Malaysia Houzao and Indian Houzao. J Chin Herb Med. 1984;5:23.Google Scholar
- Derong Z, Jichang L. Identification of Houzao and similar products. J Chin Herb Med. 1979;4:36.Google Scholar
- Yu J, Tian JG, Lu Y, Zhao B, Zheng Q. X-ray powder diffraction analysis of Indian Houzao and Malaysia Houzao. Chin Pharm Affairs. 2002;16(2):101–3.Google Scholar
- Zhige Xue, Jianwen Yi. Review of Houzao. Chin J Ethnomed Ethnopharm. 1996;18(1):39–41.Google Scholar
- Ren S. Houzao is not a concretion from a macaque. J Fam Chin Med. 1994;1:51.Google Scholar
- Rowling JK. Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. It is mentioned in Book One, “A bezoar is a stone taken from the stomach of a goat and it will save you from most poisons.”. London: Bloomsbury Pub; 1997. p. 102.Google Scholar
- Zhaozhan L, Yuansheng Z, Ling C, Gu L, Jiang Y, Li C, Zhu C. Study on the chemical constituents of Houzao. Trad Chin Drug Res Clin Pharmacol. 2017;28(4):509–12.Google Scholar
- Xie Z. “Continuity of Varieties of Medicinal Materials” and “Variations in Varieties of Medicinal Materials”. Discussion on the varieties of Chinese materia medica. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press; 1990. p. 45.Google Scholar